Bought these for the hubs for his birthday. Unless it's snowing - which is rare - he prefers a broadcloth pajama for winter, and the two sets he had were appearing in the laundry at an alarming rate. The fabric is really nice, and the piping trim looks great. He says they're very comfortable, and does not complain about wrinkles (honestly, not sure he would ever notice - I shove winkles in the sheets underneath him), buttons that don't stay latched (that, he would notice) or scratchy fabric (something that I would notice immediately. Me, I wear nice soft flannel). He seems very happy with them.
I bought size XL, because that's his shirt (neck etc.) size. I really struggle with sizes for men these days, because it seems like sometimes size XL is the natural progression from size Large, and sometimes XL is the size for Godzilla's neolithic ancestors. This time, it turned out that XL was the size for Godzilla's somewhat smaller nephew. So, the hubs has some pajamas that are a little long in the arms and legs; I hear him cursing because he gets the sleeves wet when he's making coffee. The PJs are also a little roomy in the bum, but who knows? He might need that someday soon. Ideally these would have been slightly smaller for the perfect fit ... but then, ideally I would have remembered that I already see blue pajamas every week in the laundry and bought him another color instead. We all have our challenges.
The fabric is great and unless he finds the size to be a problem, he might be seeing these again in another color in a gift bag on the next gift-giving occasion. The lucky guy.