I originally bought the black-on-black version after seeing in a store (for $60 more) and loved it--I've gotten tons of compliments on the look. So I decided to dare the gray-on-black as well. It's also very nice, and not too extreme--the gray is fairly dark and nicely complimentary. As for the jackets themselves, the pros include a very comfortable fit (the poly shell has a nice bit of give). And yes, all the pockets work once you cut them open, including the angular chest pockets (giving 6 total). The only cons were easily fixed: I wear a 44 Short jacket, so I had to take the sleeves up about 2", which was a bit of a trick with the cuff piping, but the end result is quite acceptable. Also, they come in bags, so there's some pressing and steaming to do.

If you like western style or just don't want the staid conservative sport jacket look, this is a very nice option with a bit of flair. I've become a huge fan of Scully products. And you can't beat the price.

Really great. Looks, feels, and seems to be made high quality. So many compliments. I got the black with black embroidery to be subtle. Have worn it twice: once with black dress pants and tie for a dress up occasion and once with jeans for a party. Couldn't be happier.

The only thing with this jacket for me is sleeve length, it needs to be an inch shorter.

Bought one for my dad and my husband liked it so much I got one for him too!

quality as expected from Scully. Great material and as beautiful of an item as you see in the pics. A hair large but Scully is a great grand, I have many of their items. Quality stuff.

Husband loved!

I'm 6'6" 300lbs. Usually wear 52L. This fit amazing and I get a lot of compliments on it

Great quality material and workmanship.