I really want to love these shirts, and I continue to wear them, but they're too problematic to suggest people buy them (at least the ones I got). I bought the Mustard and Brick ones, so this may not apply to all of them.
* They fit as expected
* The colors were what I thought they would be, based on the pictures
* Kind of cheaply made. There were threads hanging out at places, and certain seams look like they're going to come apart. I don't think they will come apart, but it looks like it.
* This is the worst part, and I don't know what causes it. But every time I wash and dry the shirts, they end up with spots all over them. I can't figure out if it's the dye bleeding, or if it's a reaction to fabric softener sheets, or what. It's very annoying, though. I think washing them with white vinegar instead of detergent, and not using fabric softener sheets might help a little, but I haven't quite figured it out yet.
* I bought the 19-19 1/2 36-37 size, which means I'm a big, tall guy. I'm 6'2" and 230 lbs. The ties that came with the shirts were a little too short. You'd think they would adjust the tie length based on bigger shirt sizes. I was able to make them work by using paper clips in the back, but they're a little shorter than I would like them to be.
Overall, the shirts are usable, and they would look fairly nice if it weren't for the spots. But too many problems to suggest these. Where can a guy get a good dress shirt with a 19-19 1/2 neck? None of the stores around me go that high, and you just can't trust the quality online. By the time you wash them and see a bunch of spots, it's too late to send them back!